4.5 stars
Buzzword Title Challenge 25: Water words
Scarlett Vandermeer is struggling, both with her academic subjects at Stanford and her diving. While physically fully recovered from a bad accident a year ago, Scarlett has a block that prevents her from even attempting the type of dive that had her hospitalised and having to go through several surgeries to fix her broken body. She needs to get her grades up if she wants to get into med school, and she has reluctantly agreed to go to therapy to see if she can get past the mental block that is hindering her diving but doesn’t really feel as if it’s working.
Lucas Blomquist is a world champion swimmer and has won multiple Olympic medals. He’s one of Stanford’s top aquatic athletes and the loyal boyfriend of Scarlett’s diving teammate Penelope. When Lucas and Penelope quietly break up, however, Penelope drunkenly suggests that Lucas and Scarlett hook up, because “they’re into the same thing”, BDSM. While Lucas is apparently a great, loyal and caring boyfriend, sexually he and Penelope just aren’t compatible, because Pen isn’t into kink at all. Scarlett, however, is. After a few weeks of extreme awkwardness around both Pen and Lucas, she and Lucas actually communicate and discover that their kinks seem to be extremely well-matched. Scarlett is wary about starting anything with her friend’s ex, but once she and Lucas spend more time together, she can’t really help herself, and they agree on a mutually beneficial arrangement.
For reasons known best to herself, Pen doesn’t really want to publically break up with Lucas, so Scarlett and Lucas can’t really be public with their hook-ups. Soon they are nevertheless spending a lot of time together, working for the same professor on a biology project, and getting more and more obsessed with one another. Scarlett’s history with PTSD and her self-esteem issues make it difficult for her to trust anyone. Her growing friendship with Penelope also makes her unsure about her relationship with Lucas, are they really as over each other as they claim?
I understand that Ali Hazelwood’s books aren’t for everyone and that her writing style can be annoying. By now, it’s becoming obvious that to me, her writing works perfectly for me, and with each new thing she publishes, I like her even more. I also love that as she becomes more successful as a writer, she publishes stories she’s clearly wanted to write for a long time. She gets criticised for writing the same story over and over, and yes, she does have a tendency to feature huge, hulking guys and vulnerable petite heroines. Would I love for her to have a towering, Amazonian heroine and a short king hero in the future? Absolutely. But she’s been changing up her formula more and more. In the last two years, she’s written YA, and paranormal romance (book 2 is out in October!) and exploration of kink is getting more prominent in some of her books. I’ve seen some people say this is her best book to date, but I still think I prefer Not in Love and Love, Theoretically. Part of that is because Scarlett and Lucas both felt so young (this is definitely New Adult) and part of it is because of Penelope.
Full review here.