I do not know how to write up Don’t Trust Fish by Neil Sharpson and illustrator Dan Santat, other than to say, read it and find out what you think. I cannot tell you that on this one. The story is simple, a narrator starts with “this is a dog, cat, etc…” and what they do, characteristics, etc. and then, “This is a Fish, do not trust them.” Um…okay. And then we go through the book about fish and trust issues. Things are cute and clever, and not for everyone because sometimes the humor is subtle and sometimes not. Sometimes the story makes sense and sometimes not. It is a person by person story.
When I realized it was Santat for the artist (I really was not paying attention to the author or illustrator names) it was because I said to myself, “Huh. That-looks-familiar-is-that-Dan S?” (you know, all at once). And sure enough yup. So, the artwork is fun to read as well. It compliments the goofy nature of the story and is totally his signature style once you realize it is him, as at first it wasn’t exactly him. It is complicated. The book is complicated. But fun. I read via an online reader copy, but you can find your copy in April 2025.
However, I do know what to write about Fiona and the Peculiar Praise by Rennie Dyball and illustrator Maine Diaz. Due in mid-May 2025, I also read this via an online reader copy. This is a “step back” from how we talk about people, with their looks first and their accomplishments second. If we mention their accomplishments at all. While the story is not original, the form is and a great way to introduce the subject without being preachy.
Finoa is a clever cat. She likes to hunt mice to protect her people and neighbors. She doesn’t do beauty rest, but she recuperates for the hard work of that. No, you shouldn’t call her pretty, or lovely, after all, that is an odd thing to say to the being that told you it was time for breakfast. Sure, in the end we realize that being smart and clever is important, praising the accomplishments is a good thing, and so what if you wear a crown while you are doing it all? Nothing wrong with a little fancy now and again.
And I know what to say about the illustrations of Diaz. They are cute, lovely, fluffy, fun, and sweet. They are smart and clever, and not really action packed, but they do get the job done (seeing the mouse play dead is worth the price of admission). The colors are good, soft and compliment things and are a background character that supports not overwhelms. I might not go “Wow best book.” But I will go, “Dang! It is good. Yah. Good.”