First, let me get the work stuff out of the way, though it is available, I read Pamela S Turner’s book via an online reader copy.
Overall, Comet Chaser: The True Cinderella Story of Caroline Herschel, the First Professional Woman Astronomer, is a beautiful book. The story is what you expect: in a time when girls were housekeepers, got married and had little to no education, we find Herschel as a child, watch her grow and finally see the woman she would become. She is literally the servant to her mother and the household. When she is allowed to live with an older brother who lives in England, she starts her scientific (and musical) career. Here she and her brother would discover amazing things about astronomy. Their inventions and more are still used today or were the bases of what we have today. And of course, we see how people assumed Herschel was just her brother’s assistant and not an actual scientist. Eventually, she would give up music to proceed with her scientific endeavors.
The illustrations are romantic, dreamy and realistic. They fit the theme, are somber, but also upbeat. They are the right colors and details to help support the story. Vivien Mildenberger is the illustrator behind them. The art is bold without being over the top, overwhelming or really taking over. Yet, it is there and will not be denied. It says “Look at me.”
It would be good for the classroom situation, but the one-on-one might not work as well. However, if read aloud, it might take a bit to get through, so take your time and try and break it down. 